• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Topics
    • Administrating Excellence
    • Building the Office
    • COVID-19
    • Growing the Practice
    • Leading the Team
    • Making the Clinic Work
    • Medical Students/Residents
    • Using Health IT
  • Allscripts EHR Training Videos
  • Podcast
  • Resources
    • Case Studies
    • Checklists
    • Infographics
    • White Papers
  • Member Area
  • Member Login
  • Register

SBGM

Knowledge to Transform Your Medical Practice

Great Leaders: Consensus Makers or Dictators?

By Jim Geyer MD

Great leaders need to be consensus makers

Got an issue that needs to be dealt with in the office? Everyone does—that’s why we created SBGM. Great leadership requires effective management and active listening. It also takes a thoughtful approach to how problems are addressed. Are you going to sit down with all concerned parties and work through to a consensus? Or will you go to the opposite end of the spectrum and simply “lay down the law” without any input from others? Consensus-maker sounds so much more appealing. Dictator sounds ruthless. In real-world medicine, the truth is there is room for a bit of both.

Underpinning much of this discussion is the understanding that you absolutely must have a well-constructed, meaningful, and easily understood policy and procedure manual for your practice. Each employee should not only be given a copy of this manual but should also be educated on its contents. You may even go as far as having quizzes about the manual and giving public recognition when individuals know the manual well.

When to Dictate

For certain rules, especially those that have to do with personal or financial security, decision-making needs to be consistent, decisive, fair, and speedy. These situations are not the place for building consensus and spending additional time with meetings that will not alter decision-making. At this point, it is more important to behave like a benevolent dictator. Even in this case, however, the background and the thought processes behind the decision-making should be clearly understood and communicated. Not only does this help ensure that this type of event does not recur, it also builds trust among all members of the practice.

Being a dictator all the time, on the other hand, is a recipe for disaster. Making every decision on your own without input from your staff is likely to create an adversarial relationship. Why create additional headaches? We have enough of them as it is. Avoid being a dictator just to get things done quickly. The short-term time investment is far less than the costs of poorly followed processes, dysfunctional work culture, and negative energies in the long run.

When to Find Consensus

Trying to work through every policy decision and every new office rule with the staff and physicians in order to ensure all parties completely understand and completely agree with the decision and the reasoning behind the decision is both time-consuming and unrewarding. It is best to build consensus when consensus is important—when it will improve outcome. A group that is involved in the system is more likely to support the system.

Being Effective With Both

In the vast majority of cases, it is very important to work with the team to develop a plan. In part, this can be considered consensus-making. It is important to get the ideas and thoughts of all those involved. Always remember that you are not necessarily the smartest person in the room. Your employees very likely know far more about their jobs than you do. Listen to them and incorporate their ideas into your plans—even when it does not change the overall plan, inclusion creates team. It is possible that by the time the meeting is over, each person leaving the room may believe that the idea being enacted was in fact their own. The commitment to executing the plan created by that sense is invaluable.

Don’t forget the active listening and clear communication. Make sure your staff understands the decision-making and your expectations for them. Do not assume that they understood. This is especially true when there is a new rule that on its surface may not seem to make sense. Make sure that your team understands that you are grateful for their input and that they are all very important for shared success.

Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to join the conversation about leadership in medicine.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Share the knowledge to transform your practice

Filed Under: Leading the Team, Latest Articles Tagged With: Health Care Practice Dynamics, Leading the Team, Making Medicine Fun Again

Primary Sidebar

Tags

Accounting for Physicians Administering Excellence Administrative Excellence Building the Office Building the Practice Burnout Clinical Trials Compensation COVID-19 Cybersecurity Electronic Health Records embezzlement Emotional Intelligence Finance Growing the Practice health care accounting Health Care Practice Dynamics Health IT Human Resources Improving Outcomes Leading the Team Making Medicine Fun Again Making the Clinic Work Medical Appointment Scheduling medical practice accounting medical practice banking Medical Practice Embezzlement Medical Practice Expenses Medical Practice Finances Medical Practice Revenue Medical Schools Medical Students Patient Education Patient Engagement Phone Tree Practice Manager Prior Authorization Residency Scheduling Scheduling Software Staff Engagement Taxes Using Health Care IT Voice Assistants Voice Technology
JNP Enterprises © 2025 ·
This site uses technologies such as cookies to provide a better user experience by personalizing content and ads, analysing web traffic, trends, and improving site operations. we may share information about your use of the site with third parties in accordance with our Privacy Policy. By continuing to use this site, you agree that we can save cookies on your device, unless you have disabled them. You can change your cookie settings at any time by visiting our Cookie Policy, but parts of our site may not function correctly without them.OkPrivacy policy